Skeptic Project

Your #1 COINTELPRO cognitive infiltration source.

Page By Category

Forum - What makes the Venus Project different from any other utopia cult? - Page 3

[ Add Tags ]

[ Return to General Discussion | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:37
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

>> Fair enough. What did you do to donate your time to charity?

Posting on forums, forwarding emails, etc does not count. Nothing involving Zeitgeist counts, as it is not a charity any more than Scientology is. Only real volunteer work with a legitimate, charitable organization counts. If you sat at home in front of your computer, it doesn't count.

Your initial reply about my scepticism concerning your real contributions to society made it sound like you were Mr. Peace Corps. I'd like to know what exactly it is you have done for charity. You claim to be all about saving the world. I just want to know what steps you've taken to really do something about it. <<

I really think that a awareness campaign does count as a charity, because there's really only a small difference between it and a petition campaign such as those of Amnesty International to free various political prisoners and so forth (one example of charity work I personally have been involved in when possible).

One example of an initiative I've applied to be involved in is http://www.theROADTRIP.com.au/</p>

I've also done the 40 Hour Famine (http://www.worldvision.com.au/ourwork/Solutions/40HourFamine.aspx) before, and thus facilitated the gaining of funds for the treatment of poverty.

I've also worked on a few 'community projects' and personally raised hundreds of dollars for my school back when I was about 11 years old.

I'm all for community projects under the banner of the ZM, Technocracy, TVP, or any other organization. One thing I'd love to see is an international community garden collective (perhaps there is already existing such an organization but I've yet to come across it).

As Nanos, a member on the ZM forums, has highlighted: there are government funds just waiting for us if we were to get up off our asses and apply for them. The thing is that such a thing requires high organization and specific planning - two things the Movement is not facilitating at all at this time. But I see no reason why Chapters cannot and will not start on such projects in the near future.

@Edward:
By Matriarchy I'm referring to the terminology of economist Bernard Lietar, and referenced by Ellen Brown (see the section 'When Money Could Grow'): http://www.webofdebt.com/excerpts/chapter-5.php

#61 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:38
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@OMNISCIENCE:

If you're a follower of Peter Joseph or the Zeitgeist Movement I doubt it will matter what I say. You'll either figure out its a crock on your own or you won't. As I said, you can debate Sky or advancedatheist if a debate is what you want. If its a reason to feel like a victimized minority who has a special message that people are too stupid to accept you can keep replying to me. Your choice.

#62 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:38
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

Okay, so why the insult at me?

#63 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:40
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Brenton:

So really, you raised some cash when you were 11, applied to do one thing, and did something else.

Wow. I totally buy into your technocracy-slash-fascist pop culture religion now.

This is absurd.

#64 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:43
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

@Matt:

You asked for personal examples, so I gave them.

A few examples of what I have done in my life has no relation to the relevance of Technocracy.

#65 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:43
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

@Matt
You're assuming I'm a minority in whatever sense you mean, and we all know what that does :)

@Sky
So really, what is the problem you have with TVP? why do you see it as no different from any other "Utopian cult"

#66 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:43
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Brenton:

Yeah it has a lot of bearing when you make statements like this:

"I work with every decent organization I have the breath in my lungs, health and time to do so including such groups as Amnesty International and 'MakePovertyHistory'."

That is pretty much a flat out lie.

#67 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:44
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

@Matt:

No it's not.

#68 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
SkyPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:45
(0)
 

Level: 3
CS Original

This thread is getting excedingly directionless. I suggest that Matt calms down, and Omni-Science gets back on the topic that everyone else is talking about or make a new thread if you have some kind of point to make.

#69 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:46
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Brenton:

How do you equate raising money when you were 11, doing one charity event, and applying to another as "I work with every decent organization I have the breath in my lungs, health and time to do so including such groups as Amnesty International".

World Vision is a Christian based charity. It is not Amnesty International.

#70 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:47
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

@Sky
So really, what is the problem you have with TVP? why do you see it as no different from any other "Utopian cult"

#71 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:48
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

@Matt:

Why should I list every example of what I've done to help, to you? I can't think of any reason to waste my time doing that.

You're quite right about World Vision, but that doesn't make it's work irrelevant.

#72 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Edward L WinstonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:48
(0)
 

President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Herbert Camacho: porn star and five-time ultimate smackdown wrestling champion!

Level: 150
CS Original

Sky's right, let's get back to talking about The Venus Project or move it to another thread. If there's too much "motha' fuckin' ruckus", I'm going to have to close this thread.

#73 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:49
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

@Sky
So really, what is the problem you have with TVP? why do you see it as no different from any other "Utopian cult"

replying over and over again

I think im on topic now.....

#74 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:49
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Sky:

I'm pretty calm.

When someone tells me they have a grand vision for how society should be run, I think its pretty important to ask what they've done to try and achieve that grand vision. In my experience, people involved in utopian movements generally don't really do much aside from digital communications.

#75 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
SkyPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:49
(0)
 

Level: 3
CS Original

"So really, what is the problem you have with TVP? why do you see it as no different from any other "Utopian cult""

Okay, see what I mean? We are talking about so many different things and it is going no where. I never called it a "Utopian Cult", although I think I did call it a "Cult of Personality" in another thread.

#76 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:51
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

Okay so what do you think of it as?

aside from a cult of personality based on Peter Joseph?

#77 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:53
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

Anyways, the point of starting this thread was to have someone explain exactly why ZM or VP is not a utopian cult.

Here is my definition of a utopian cult: People who flock around some charismatic oddball who claims that he has the answers to all the world's problems if only people weren't so damn stupid.

From what I have seen from Peter Joseph and Fresco, it leads me to believe this stuff is just another (by my definition) utopian cult.

That's what this thread is supposed to be about, so if you can show otherwise feel free.

#78 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:54
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

>> When someone tells me they have a grand vision for how society should be run, I think its pretty important to ask what they've done to try and achieve that grand vision. <<

Every step in the direction toward right human relations is a step toward a 'grand vision'. Be that step a spiritual (value oriented), political, philosophical, technological or a wider social one. Much like doing a puzzle.

>> People who flock around some charismatic oddball who claims that he has the answers to all the world's problems if only people weren't so damn stupid. <<
It's not Fresco, nor Joseph, nor 'The Venus Project'. It's the ideas within, which are so obviously not uniquely Jacque's. It's the subject of his life's influences, seemingly most prominently Technocracy (http://www.technocracy.org/).
Which is, of course, not a cult.

#79 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:56
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Brenton:

"Every step in the direction toward right human relations is a step toward a 'grand vision'. Be that step a spiritual (value oriented), political, philosophical, technological or a wider social one. Much like doing a puzzle."

You can't eat a puzzle.

#80 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Edward L WinstonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:57
(0)
 

President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Herbert Camacho: porn star and five-time ultimate smackdown wrestling champion!

Level: 150
CS Original

Well you've got a puzzle with 7 billion pieces and you only know how 36,000 or so fit together. Did I mention this puzzle is a 4 dimensional puzzle?

#81 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:58
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

Please, it was an analogy at best. ;)

#82 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 07, 2010 - 23:58
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

@Brenton:

So you're saying that the Zeitgeist Movement or Venus Project could operate just as effectively without Fresco or Joseph?

#83 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:01
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

@Matt:

Yep. That's the whole point of establishing Chapter's all over the globe, so that their influence is not a requisite.

#84 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:01
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

Every major movement needs an icon to some degree

Be it a person or symbol

key words: Some degree

#85 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:02
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

@Omni:
Not really. I'm willing to bet that the early Anglo-Americans didn't idolize the founding fathers as they are now - they just liked their ideas, because at that time they worked.

#86 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Edward L WinstonPosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:03
(0)
 

President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Herbert Camacho: porn star and five-time ultimate smackdown wrestling champion!

Level: 150
CS Original

I think that's the central argument for democratic centralism, but we learned from Marxism-Leninism that vanguards with "icons" tend to be corrupted and lose track of what their goals are (helping the working class).

The best bet is to have absolutely no icon, cult of personality, etc. Have a set of goals that people collectively more or less agree on.

Edit: (What Brenton said)

#87 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Agent MattPosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:04
(0)
 

Genuine American Monster

Level: 70
CS Original

I just don't understand how one could believe that a movement that is unwilling to organize when it has established leaders would do so when it doesn't.

That makes no real sense to me.

#88 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
BrentonPosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:06
(0)
 

Level: 0
CS Original

>> The best bet is to have absolutely no icon, cult of personality, etc. Have a set of goals that people collectively more or less agree on. <<
And therein lies the goal of establishing right human relations. Which is something no one really talked much about until the United Nations, which as I've said on a news article on flu pandemics on your blog, is an organization that just doesn't get enough credit.
Unfortunately the UN aim is softened a little but and it really just serves as a "forum for the nations" at this stage. Which is still great, but it could go further.

@Matt:
Organization takes time. Especially when your aim is global unity.

#89 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]
Omni-SciencePosted: Feb 08, 2010 - 00:06
(0)
 

Ordo Ab Chao.

Level: 8
CS Original

*guffaws*

*kneeslaps*

Your rants can get entertaining, Matt

I needed a pick me up

#90 [ Top | Reply to Topic ]