Tags: false flag [ Add Tags ]
[ Return to General Discussion | Reply to Topic ] |
AKBastard | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 07:13 |
| ||||
Level: 5 CS Original | I sometimes hear truthers (Alex Jones included) talking about how the Nazis supposedly blamed the communists for burning down the Reichstag, when it was in fact the Nazis themselves, using it as an excuse to persecute communists and other political parties in Nazi Germany. This is supposed to justify belief in 9/11 conspiracies. Did this actually happen or is it just more bullshit? I've seen conflicting articles on the subject. | |||||
#1 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Von Kleist | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 07:39 |
| ||||
Level: 1 CS Original | Most historians believe that the Reichstag fire was started by Marius Van der Lubbe,a Dutch communist, and that the Nazis used this as an opportunity to pass legislation allowing the enacting of legislation without the assent of the German Parliament. So it was basically opportunism, rather than a plot. There is no compelling evidence of the Nazis having started the fire themselves. As to the comparison with 9/11, the Nazis had took a major step to dictatorship within a month of the fire. 9 years later they were in control of most of western Europe, had all political opponents locked up in concentration camps and had begun the implementation of the Final Solution. The NWO, 9 years on from 9/11, has managed to cause some inconvenience to its opponents by implementing body-scanners at some airports. | |||||
#2 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Muertos | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 10:52 |
| ||||
Paid Disinformation Blogger Level: 14 CS Original | Argonessen is right. An actually true example of a real "false flag" is very tough to find. The Gliewitz radio station attack in Poland in 1939 is the only one I can think of, but it almost doesn't count because absolutely no one believed it. CT's love to claim the Reichstag fire, Gulf of Tonkin and Operation Northwoods as false flags. None of them actually were. But CT'ers get history as wrong as they do everything else, so why should this be any different? | |||||
#3 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Agent Matt | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 11:21 |
| ||||
Genuine American Monster Level: 70 CS Original | A real false flag would be nearly impossible to pull off. There's no way you'd be able to keep the amount of personnel needed to be completely silent. How do you keep one from blabbing it to his wife or a friend or something? It relies on a very Hollywood-ish view of the world. | |||||
#4 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Edward L Winston | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 14:06 |
| ||||
President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Herbert Camacho: porn star and five-time ultimate smackdown wrestling champion! Level: 150 CS Original | The Reichstag Fire is just an example of getting lucky in order to push an agenda, nothing more. Spindoctors like Alex Jones like to claim said Dutch communist was "mentally retarded" and "blind" but neither are true. I find it also funny how Alex Jones always brings up the PATRIOT Act and compares it to the Reichstag Fire Decree (which he incorrectly calls the Enabling Act, which is something different). The idea you could compare a bill that adds a lot of gray area in order to fight terrorism, to a bill that suspended freedom of speech, freedom of association, freedom of due process, etc. is just completely asinine and shows what a total liar, or moron, you really are. Like the morons that keep commenting on this video: It takes a lot of blind faith in order to believe in people like Alex Jones, suspending disbelief makes you a religious person, not a smart one. | |||||
#5 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Olek_L | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 15:15 |
| ||||
Level: 0 CS Original | @Muertos: The shelling of Mainila, an incident used by Soviets as a pretext to invade Finland in 1939 may be another example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shelling_of_Mainila</p> But again, it was a rather thinly veiled false flag. | |||||
#6 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
lylen | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 17:05 |
| ||||
Level: 0 CS Original | The Mancurian incident was fairly effective. In this case you had a population that was never really given a chance to question the motives (small democracy movements that had some tiny success during the Taisho democracy movement were held in check) and an emperor that was more than happy to cave to military fanaticism (since it was done in his name anyway). | |||||
#7 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
Agent Matt | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 17:45 |
| ||||
Genuine American Monster Level: 70 CS Original | The problem with simply labelling The Manchurian Incident as a successful false flag in the same context that conspiracy theorists use it is that there is no definitive evidence that it was carried out by any orders from Tokyo. So again, we have a case where its entirely possible that the Japanese government simply capitalized on a situation they did not actually stage. | |||||
#8 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
AKBastard | Posted: Jan 02, 2011 - 18:10 |
| ||||
Level: 5 CS Original | "It takes a lot of blind faith in order to believe in people like Alex Jones" I sometimes use the argument that we know a terrorist shot up Fort Hood, we know a terrorist from Nigeria was the Christmas Day bomber, we know that a terrorist tried to blow up a Christmas tree in Oregon over the holidays. So why is 9/11 any different? "Those other guys were under mind control! Read about MK-Ultra!" Shit like that makes ME want to strap a bomb to my chest. | |||||
#9 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
lylen | Posted: Jan 03, 2011 - 01:55 |
| ||||
Level: 0 CS Original | Matt, you're right, the Manchurian incident was plotted by the army from what I read in Herbert Bix book "Hirohito and the making of Modern Japan", and some other history texts. It was capitalized upon by the generals and Emperor. However, I read it was the intention of the Mancurian army to force some kind of conflict. Guess that wouldn't be called "false flag" though. | |||||
#10 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
The Real Roxette | Posted: Jan 03, 2011 - 12:11 |
| ||||
There ARE more sluts in public schools. Shut up and let me explain. Level: 8 CS Original | The mentioned false-flag attacks above still pale in comparison to major things like 9/11 or even small things like the IRS-building attack. The idea you can compare simply firing at made up enemies and it starting a war to a complex series of secret events involving hundreds of people is simply stupid. It's one thing to say "hey, they shot at us, *bang, bang, bang*" and another to fake phone calls from airplanes, setup thermite, etc. all without anyone noticing or ever saying anything. False-flag now is just a way to say everything bad that happens in the world is a part of some vast conspiracy; it's really no different than when people say "God did it!" it surrenders thinking for yourself in the name of an ideology. I imagine if the NWO didn't exist, nothing bad would ever happen. Bill Cooper would still be alive, we'd all have tons of gold, and Alex Jones wouldn't be fat. | |||||
#11 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |
lylen | Posted: Jan 03, 2011 - 18:09 |
| ||||
Level: 0 CS Original | Killed it, good job | |||||
#12 | [ Top | Reply to Topic ] |